CIR Jurisprudences: subcontracting expenses

Case law - Cancellation of the restrictive doctrine of April 4, 2014 regarding subcontracting 

The Council of State annulled the administrative doctrine below found in the second paragraph of paragraph 220 of BOI-BIC-RICI-10-10-20-30 dated April 4, 2014, as well as its quantified example.

“The approved organization must then deduct from the basis for calculating its own research tax credit the sums received from organizations for which the research operations are carried out and invoiced (CGI, art. 244 quater B, III). The purpose of this provision is to prevent the same research operations from giving rise to the right to the tax credit twice.


Company A orders a specific research operation from an approved body B. In consideration for the service provided, A pays B the sum of € 10,000.

Company A will take into account the sum of € 10,000 in the basis for calculating its tax credit.

In return, organization B will deduct the same amount of € 10,000 from the basis for calculating its own tax credit. "

This doctrine had the effect of obliging approved private research organizations subcontracting to include in the basis of their Research Tax Credit (CIR) the amount of eligible expenses incurred in the context of research operations carried out on behalf of eligible third parties, before deduce the amount of the invoicing sent to its principal.

The Council of State annulled this doctrine, ruling that the provisions of article 244 quater b of the CGI must be interpreted as prohibiting approved private research organizations from including in the basis for calculating their own research tax credit the expenses incurred to carry out research operations on behalf of third parties.

Thus, approved private research organizations carrying out research expenses on behalf of a third party do not have to include the amount of expenses incurred in the base of their CIR and to deduct therefrom the total amount of the sums invoiced in remuneration of these benefits.

An approved subcontractor can therefore now do without re-invoiced projects and only declare transactions carried out for its own account in order to benefit from the same advantages in terms of CIR as a non-approved organization on its internal projects.


Source: CE, September 9, 2020, 440523

Case law - First feedback on the application of the Council of State's position in terms of valuing the subcontracting services necessary for carrying out research operations


In a judgment of August 5, 2020, the Strasbourg Administrative Court considered that subcontracting expenses essential to the completion of research projects carried out by the principal could be considered eligible at the latter even though they were did not in themselves correspond to real clearly individualized research and development operations.

This therefore reinforces the declarants in their legitimacy to follow this approach as part of their declaration.


Source : TA de Strasbourg, 5 August 2020, 1807359


See the rest

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Articles in Relationship

The research tax credit is exported to Germany: GAC too!

We told you about it a few months ago, it's now official: the German finance committee has (finally) approved the draft law on tax incentives for R&D! This “boost” to innovation falls perfectly with the current opening of our offices in Munich. Indeed, after


Press release - Renewal of the request for early repayment of tax credit debts before the filing of the tax package By a press release dated March 2, 2021, Bruno Le Maire, the Minister of the Economy, Finance and Recovery , announced new tax measures to support businesses

Staff costs

Case law - Reminder: Eligibility of research technicians with regard to the application of the definition - February 2021 In a judgment of February 24, 2021, the Council of State confirms that research technicians can be valued in the CIR for companies, whatever their training. As a reminder, to promote a technician of

Keep in touch !Subscribe to the newsletter

* Please fill in the required fields.

In accordance with the provisions of the regulations on the protection of personal data, GAC, as data controller, processes your data in order to respond to your request related to GAC products and services.
In accordance with the regulations in force, you have the right to access, rectify, delete and oppose your personal data. You can assert these rights by contacting our DPO at: and by proving your identity. You can also lodge a complaint with the CNIL. Learn more.

Scroll to Top